Abstract:
|
Our work concerns Frege systems,
substitution Frege systems (sF),
renaming Frege systems, top/bottom-Frege systems and
extended Frege systems (eF).
Urquhart shows that tautologies associated to a binary
strings require Omega(n/log n) lines
to be proved in sF.
Here we prove, by giving a sF proof
of O(n/log n) lines in substitution Frege, that his
lower bound is optimal and we show that
in the tree-like case
Omega(n) lines are required for a proof
of the same tautologies.
We also show the following two simulation results:
(1) tree-like substitution Frege p-simulates non
tree-like substitution Frege; (2) Tree-like Frege
linearly simulates tree-like renaming Frege
and tree-like top/bottom-Frege. |