Opinion on the benefits of nurse prescribing in Catalonia: consensus of health professionals and managers

Abstract

Prescripció infermera; Infermeria

Prescripción enfermera; Enfermería

Nurse prescribing; Nursing

Objective: To study the level of agreement among health professionals and managers in Catalonia on the benefits of nurse prescribing (NP). Method: An online Real Time Delphi was conducted to collect the level of agreement of health professionals and managers. Participants voted in a 6-point scale (1 low benefit and 6 high benefit) for 12 items describing benefits of NP. A total of 1332 professionals participated. The level of consensus was calculated applying interquartile ranges of scores and standardized mean differences among subgroups using effect sizes (ES) and their corresponding 95% confidence intervals. Results: The scores indicate a general agreement on the perceived benefits of NP among participants. Standardized differences among scores on the perceived benefits among professionals were small to high (ES range between 0.2 and 1.2) between nurses and medical doctors and high between nurses and pharmacists (ES range: 1.2 and 2.4). Differences between scores of nurses and those of managers or other professionals in the present study were smaller for most voted benefits. Conclusions: The study shows an agreement on the benefits of NP. Nevertheless, when standardized scores are taken into consideration, differences among professionals’ perceptions emerged, and aligned with documented barriers identified in the literature such as corporative aspects, cultural limitations, institutional and organisational inertia, beliefs and unawareness of what NP implies.

Objetivo: Estudiar el nivel de consenso entre profesionales de salud y gestores en Cataluna˜ sobre los beneficios de la prescripción enfermera (PE). Método: Se realizó un Delphi en tiempo real en línea para recoger el nivel de acuerdo de profesionales de la salud y gestores. Las personas participantes votaron en una escala de 6 puntos (1 bajo beneficio y 6 alto beneficio) en 12 ítems que describen los beneficios de la PE. Participaron 1332 profesionales. El nivel de consenso se calculó aplicando rangos intercuartílicos de puntuaciones y diferencias de medias estandarizadas entre subgrupos a partir de tamanos ˜ del efecto (ES) y sus correspondientes intervalos de confianza del 95%. Resultados: Las puntuaciones indican un acuerdo general sobre los beneficios percibidos de la PE entre las personas participantes. Las diferencias estandarizadas entre las puntuaciones sobre los beneficios percibidos entre profesionales fueron de pequenas ˜ a altas (rango ES: 0,2 a 1,2) entre enfermeras ymédicos, y altas entre enfermeras y farmacéuticos (rango ES: 1,2 a 2,4). Las diferencias entre las puntuaciones de profesionales de enfermería y gestión clínica u otros profesionales en el presente estudio fueron menores para los beneficios más votados. Conclusiones: El estudio muestra un acuerdo sobre los beneficios de la PE. Sin embargo, cuando se tienen en cuenta las puntuaciones estandarizadas se encontraron algunas diferencias entre las percepciones de profesionales y se alinearon con las barreras documentadas identificadas en la literatura, como aspectos corporativos, limitaciones culturales, inercia institucional y organizativa, creencias y desconocimiento de lo que implica la PE.

The present study has not received a specific funding. The Agency of Health Quality and Assessment of Catalonia (AQuAS) signed a collaboration agreement with the Council of Nurses and Infermers Colleges of Catalonia (CIIC) and the Family and Community Nursing Association of Catalonia (AIFiCC) to carry out the study. The project was partially financed by AQuAS and the budget of Group 15 of the Spanish scientific network Consorcio Centro de Investigación Biomédica (CIBER) in Epidemiology and Public Health (CIBERESP). The Spanish Biomedical Network- CIBER financed the Health Delphi platform applied in this consensus study. The revision of English grammar was carried out by a native linguist financed by the CCIIC.